Common Carp lakes in Pennsylvania

Common Carp lakes from PFBC's lists and surveys.

We don't rate lakes; these are PFBC listings and PFBC survey records.

On the PFBC Best Fishing Waters list (Nov 2024)

• Bridgeport Reservoir Fayette Co. PFBC Best Fishing Waters (Nov 2024)
• Conneaut Lake Crawford Co. PFBC Best Fishing Waters (Nov 2024)
• Foster Joseph Sayers Lake Centre Co. PFBC Best Fishing Waters (Nov 2024)
• Hammond Lake Tioga Co. PFBC Best Fishing Waters (Nov 2024)
• Keystone Lake Armstrong Co. PFBC Best Fishing Waters (Nov 2024)
• Lake Arthur (Moraine State Park) Butler Co. PFBC Best Fishing Waters (Nov 2024)
• Lake Galena Bucks Co. PFBC Best Fishing Waters (Nov 2024)
• Lake Marburg (Codorus State Park) York Co. PFBC Best Fishing Waters (Nov 2024)
• Lake Wilhelm Mercer Co. PFBC Best Fishing Waters (Nov 2024)
• Pinchot Lake (State Park) York Co. PFBC Best Fishing Waters (Nov 2024)
• Raystown Lake Huntingdon Co. PFBC Best Fishing Waters (Nov 2024)
• Shawnee Lake (State Park) Bedford Co. PFBC Best Fishing Waters (Nov 2024)
• Shenango River Lake Mercer Co. PFBC Best Fishing Waters (Nov 2024)

Recorded in a PFBC survey since 2016

• Dunlap Creek Lake Fayette Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2025 survey
• Dutch Fork Lake Washington Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2025 survey
• Peters Twp. Lake (Res. #2) Washington Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2025 survey
• Pymatuning Reservoir Crawford Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2025 survey
• Cross Creek Lake Washington Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2024 survey
• Francis E Walter Reservoir Luzerne Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2024 survey
• Speedwell Forge Lake Lancaster Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2024 survey
• Tamarack Lake Crawford Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2024 survey
• Hopewell Lake Berks Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2023 survey
• Lackawanna Lake (State Park) Lackawanna Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2023 survey
• Laurel Hill Lake Somerset Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2023 survey
• Marshall Lake Allegheny Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2023 survey
• Briar Creek Lake Columbia Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2022 survey
• Lake Rowena Cambria Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2022 survey
• Marsh Creek Lake (State Park) Chester Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2022 survey
• North Park Lake Allegheny Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2022 survey
• Tioga Reservoir Tioga Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2022 survey
• Acme Dam Westmoreland Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2021 survey
• Blue Marsh Reservoir Berks Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2021 survey
• Canoe Creek Lake (State Park) Blair Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2021 survey
• Cowanesque Lake Tioga Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2021 survey
• Lake Redman York Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2021 survey
• Lake Towhee Bucks Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2021 survey
• Lake Wallenpaupack Pike Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2021 survey
• Wilmore Dam Cambria Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2021 survey
• Lake Oneida Butler Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2020 survey
• Struble Lake Chester Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2020 survey
• Canonsburg Lake Washington Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2019 survey
• Cranberry Glade Lake Somerset Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2019 survey
• Cummings Reservoir (aka Blue Spruce Lake) Indiana Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2019 survey
• Glade Dam Lake Butler Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2019 survey
• Main Lake (Raccoon Creek Lake) Beaver Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2019 survey
• Mammoth Dam Westmoreland Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2019 survey
• Lower Burrel Park Pond (Holtzhauer Lake) Westmoreland Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2018 survey
• Loyalhanna Lake Westmoreland Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2018 survey
• Mahoning Creek Lake Armstrong Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2018 survey
• Stillwater Lake Susquehanna Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2018 survey
• Twin Lakes Number One Reservoir (Lower) Westmoreland Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2018 survey
• Bradys Run Lake Beaver Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2017 survey
• Crooked Creek Lake Armstrong Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2017 survey
• Keystone Lake (State Park) Westmoreland Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2017 survey
• Sugar Lake Crawford Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2017 survey
• Green Lick Reservoir Fayette Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2016 survey
• Leboeuf Lake Erie Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2016 survey
• Nockamixon Lake (State Park) Bucks Co. Recorded in PFBC's 2016 survey

Find Common Carp lakes near your county

Sources: PFBC Best Fishing Waters lake layers (list of Nov 2024); PFBC biologist reports. Last data import Oct 5, 2026.